From Copper Coins to Global Currency: The Evolution of Chinese Money Through the Ages

The invention of paper money in China, which dates back to the Tang Dynasty (618-907 AD) but became more widespread during the Song Dynasty (960-1279 AD), can be attributed to several factors unique to China’s historical, technological, and economic context. This development was indeed revolutionary, and understanding why China led in this area involves examining the broader picture of paper’s invention and use, as well as the economic needs and administrative innovations of ancient China.

Historical and Technological Context

Invention of Paper: Paper was invented in China by Cai Lun during the Eastern Han Dynasty around 105 AD. This invention provided a relatively cheap and accessible medium for writing compared to silk and bamboo, which were the primary materials for writing before paper. The widespread availability of paper in China was a crucial precondition for the invention of paper money.
Printing Technology: China was also a pioneer in developing printing technology, with the invention of woodblock printing around the 8th century. This technology allowed for the mass production of texts, including paper money, making it feasible to produce and distribute currency on a large scale.
Economic Necessity: The Song Dynasty witnessed significant economic growth, trade expansion, and urbanization, leading to the increased circulation of goods and services. The metal currency became scarce relative to the expanding economy, and carrying large quantities of metal coins became impractical for large transactions.
Government Administration: The Chinese government had a well-developed bureaucratic system capable of managing complex tasks, including the issuance and regulation of currency. The invention of paper money required not just technological means but also sophisticated administrative control to maintain its value and prevent counterfeiting.

Comparative Development

While other civilizations, such as the Egyptians, Greeks, and Romans, had developed writing materials like papyrus, parchment, and vellum, these materials were either more expensive or less suitable for mass production compared to paper. The specific combination of technological innovation, economic necessity, and administrative capability that characterized China during the Song Dynasty was unique and enabled China to become the first to invent and implement paper money as a widespread medium of exchange.

Early Usage of Money In China

China did use coins and other forms of money long before the invention of paper money. The evolution of Chinese currency reflects a complex history of innovation and adaptation to the country’s changing economic and social needs. Here’s an overview of what China used before the advent of paper money:

Early Forms of Money

Shell Money: The earliest form of currency in China was shell money, used during the Neolithic period and later. These were actual shells and later imitations made from bone, stone, and eventually metal, serving as a medium of exchange.
Metal Coins: By the Spring and Autumn period (770-476 BC) and the Warring States period (475-221 BC), various states in China began minting metal coins. These early coins were typically made of bronze and came in several shapes, including spade (bu) and knife (dao) money, reflecting their origins in practical tools.

Standardization under the Qin Dynasty

The Qin Dynasty (221-206 BC), which unified China for the first time, introduced a uniform system of currency. This system standardized the round coin with a square hole in the center, known as the Ban Liang coin. This design facilitated the use of coins, allowing them to be strung together for larger transactions, and became a model for Chinese coins for centuries.

Han Dynasty Innovations

The Han Dynasty (206 BC – 220 AD) continued to develop China’s monetary system. They introduced new coins and adjusted the weight and value of the currency to manage the economy. During this period, other forms of currency, such as gold ingots and silk, were also used for large transactions, reflecting a diversified monetary system.

Tang Dynasty and the Precursors to Paper Money

Before the widespread adoption of paper money in the Song Dynasty, the Tang Dynasty (618-907 AD) saw the emergence of “flying money” or “jiaozi.” These were promissory notes used by merchants for large transactions to avoid the inconvenience of transporting large quantities of coins over long distances. While not paper money in the modern sense, these notes represented an important step towards the development of paper currency by providing a model for the government-issued paper money that would follow.

Adoption & Usage

Once paper money was invented and began to circulate within China, its use marked a significant transformation in the economy and the way transactions were conducted. The utilization of paper money in China evolved over time, with its adoption initially localized and later becoming more widespread. Here’s an overview of how paper money was utilized within China after its invention:

Initial Adoption and Circulation

Geographical Spread: Paper money, known as “Jiaozi,” first appeared during the Song Dynasty in the 11th century, particularly in the Sichuan province, an area far from the capital that was rich in trade and commerce but often faced a shortage of copper coins. Its use spread gradually to other regions as traders and government officials recognized its convenience.
Government Involvement: Initially, paper money was issued by merchants or groups of merchants. The government, seeing the benefits and potential for control over the economy, began to regulate and eventually monopolize the issuance of paper money. By the time of the Southern Song Dynasty (1127-1279), the government was issuing official currency known as “Jiaochao.”

Utilization in Transactions

Trade and Commerce: Paper money was predominantly used in commercial transactions, both large and small. Its lightweight nature made it ideal for large transactions and long-distance trade, reducing the risk and inconvenience associated with transporting large quantities of metal coins.
Taxation and Government Fees: The government also used paper money to collect taxes and fees. This facilitated easier collection and redistribution of resources across the empire, enhancing the government’s ability to manage the economy.
Military Expenses: Paper money provided a means to efficiently fund military campaigns and pay soldiers. The ease of transporting paper money compared to metal coins was a significant advantage in mobilizing resources for defense and expansion.

Impact on Society

Increased Trade: The introduction of paper money facilitated increased trade within China. Merchants and consumers found it easier to conduct transactions, which contributed to economic growth and the expansion of markets.
Social Acceptance: While there was initial skepticism regarding the value of paper money, it gradually gained acceptance as the government guaranteed its value. The convenience of paper money, along with government backing, helped it become a widely accepted medium of exchange.
Inflation and Counterfeiting: The widespread use of paper money was not without challenges. Over-issuance by the government at times led to inflation. Additionally, counterfeiting became a problem, leading the government to implement measures to prevent it, such as changing the design and incorporating anti-counterfeiting features.

The Internationalization of Chinese Paper Money: Acceptance, Exchange, and Interaction

The use of paper money for international trade by China presents a complex picture, as the acceptance and utilization of this innovation varied significantly outside of China’s borders. While paper money became a cornerstone of the domestic economy, its role in international trade during ancient and medieval times was limited by several factors, including the varying acceptance of paper currency and the entrenched systems of trade and currency exchange that existed between different regions. Here’s an overview of how China’s paper money interacted with international trade:

Limited International Acceptance

Direct Acceptance: In the early stages of paper money’s use, its acceptance was primarily within China’s borders. Foreign merchants and states were unfamiliar with paper money and were often skeptical of its value, which was not backed by physical commodities like gold or silver but by the issuing authority’s promise. This skepticism limited the direct use of Chinese paper money in international transactions.
Exchange for Precious Metals and Goods: When engaging in international trade, Chinese merchants and officials often had to exchange paper money for more universally accepted forms of currency, such as gold, silver, or even silk and porcelain, which were highly valued in international markets. These goods and precious metals served as a more reliable and accepted medium of exchange for international transactions.

Role of Silk Road and Maritime Trade

Silk Road: The Silk Road was a network of trade routes connecting China with the Middle East, Africa, and Europe. While goods like silk, spices, and porcelain were traded along these routes, the use of paper money was limited. Transactions often relied on barter or currencies backed by precious metals.
Maritime Trade: Similarly, in maritime trade routes that connected China with Southeast Asia, the Indian subcontinent, and beyond, goods were the primary medium of exchange. Chinese merchants would exchange goods for local currencies or commodities, which could then be used to purchase items for return to China.

China’s Acceptance of Foreign Currencies

Foreign Coins in China: China accepted foreign silver and gold coins, especially during periods of active international trade. The Ming (1368-1644) and Qing (1644-1912) dynasties saw significant inflows of Spanish silver dollars, which became an important part of China’s currency system.
Exchange and Barter: In international trade, China engaged in both currency exchange and barter, depending on the partner and the nature of the trade. The Chinese government and merchants were pragmatic in their approach, accepting various forms of payment that could be used or easily converted within the domestic economy.

Did China’s Paper Money Reign Supreme in the Later Centuries (16th-20th) or Were Colonial Currencies More Dominant?

As we transition from the late 16th through the 20th century, the narrative around China’s use of paper money and its position in the global economy becomes one of significant change, influenced by internal challenges and the dynamics of global trade and imperialism. During this period, the dominance and international value of Chinese paper money faced several challenges, and the currencies of imperial colonial powers became increasingly influential. Here’s an overview of these developments:

Decline of Chinese Paper Money

Ming and Early Qing Dynasties: By the late Ming Dynasty (1368-1644) and early Qing Dynasty (1644-1912), China faced several internal problems, including inflation and counterfeiting, which undermined the value of paper money. Consequently, the use of paper currency declined, and China reverted to a silver-based economy, especially with the influx of Spanish silver from the Americas.
19th Century Challenges: The 19th century was particularly tumultuous for China, marked by internal rebellions, the Opium Wars with Britain, and the imposition of unequal treaties by Western powers and Japan. These events weakened China’s economy and its sovereignty over its trade and currency policies.

Rise of Western Currencies

Global Trade: As global trade expanded, the currencies of colonial powers, especially the British pound sterling, became dominant in international transactions. The British Empire’s vast reach and the stability and reliability of the pound sterling made it a preferred currency for international trade.
Imperial Influence: Portugal, the Dutch, the British, and later the Americans established colonies and trading posts around the world, including in Asia. Their economic and military power allowed them to dictate trade terms and currency use in many regions, often to the detriment of local currencies and economies, including China’s.
Silver Standard and Foreign Currencies in China: During the 19th and early 20th centuries, foreign silver coins were widely used in China due to the scarcity of official Chinese coinage and the disarray of the domestic monetary system. This situation was exacerbated by the demands of foreign powers and the indemnities China had to pay following various conflicts, which drained the country’s silver reserves.

20th Century and Modernization

Republic of China and Currency Reform: The early 20th century saw attempts by the Republic of China (1912-1949) to modernize and stabilize its currency system, but these efforts were often hampered by warlordism, the Japanese invasion, and civil war.
People’s Republic of China: After the establishment of the People’s Republic of China in 1949, the Chinese government undertook significant reforms to unify and stabilize its currency, reintroducing paper money (the Renminbi, RMB) as the sole legal tender and eventually establishing control over its value and international exchange.

Historical Currency Used in China (1600s-1800s)

During the 1600s, 1700s, and 1800s, China’s currency system underwent several changes, reflecting the country’s economic conditions, government policies, and external influences. Here is an overview of the currencies used in China across these centuries:

1600s (17th Century)

Silver and Copper Coins: Throughout the Ming (1368–1644) and early Qing (1644–1912) dynasties, silver and copper coins were the primary mediums of exchange. Silver, often in the form of ingots or “sycee,” was used for large transactions, taxes, and storing wealth, while copper coins were used for everyday transactions. The silver economy was prominent, with silver ingots being weighed and assessed for purity in transactions.
Paper Money: While the Ming dynasty initially issued paper money, its value deteriorated due to overprinting and lack of backing. By the 17th century, the use of paper money had largely been abandoned in favor of silver and copper currencies due to inflation and loss of confidence in paper currency.

1700s (18th Century)

Continued Use of Silver and Copper: The Qing dynasty continued the silver-based economy, with silver ingots and copper coins serving as the primary means of currency. The economy during this period was relatively stable, and the Qing government maintained a system where silver was used for large transactions and savings, while copper coins were circulated for everyday commerce.
Foreign Silver Coins: In the later part of the 18th century, foreign silver coins, especially Spanish dollars, began to circulate in coastal regions of China due to increased trade with European countries. These foreign coins were sometimes more trusted than local coinage and were used alongside traditional Chinese currencies.

1800s (19th Century)

Daoguang Emperor’s Reforms: In the early 19th century, faced with a shortage of copper for coinage and an influx of foreign silver coins, the Daoguang Emperor (reign 1820–1850) initiated reforms to standardize the currency, including attempts to introduce a uniform silver currency. However, these efforts were not entirely successful due to internal strife and the Opium Wars.
Impact of the Opium Wars: The Opium Wars (1839–1842, 1856–1860) and subsequent treaties opened China further to international trade but also led to economic destabilization. The treaties forced China to accept trade in foreign currencies and pay large indemnities in silver, affecting the domestic economy and currency stability.
Silver Crisis and the Return to Bimetallism: The late 19th century saw a global silver crisis, which devalued silver worldwide and impacted China’s silver-based economy. In response, China moved towards a bimetallic standard, attempting to stabilize the currency with both silver and copper, and later, gold.
Introduction of Modern Coinage and Paper Money: By the end of the 19th century, the Qing government began minting modern-style coins and reintroducing paper money in an effort to modernize the currency system and regain control over monetary policy. This period saw the introduction of the silver dollar coins, which became a standard currency unit.

Throughout these centuries, China’s currency system was characterized by its reliance on precious metals, with silver playing a central role. The country’s engagement with international trade, internal economic policies, and external pressures shaped the evolution of its currency system, leading to the gradual adoption of modern monetary practices by the end of the 19th century.

A Concise History of the Renminbi (Yuan)

The history of the Chinese yuan, or Renminbi (RMB), is a fascinating journey through China’s economic development, political changes, and efforts to integrate into the global financial system. Here’s an overview of the key milestones in the history of the yuan/Renminbi:

Introduction of the Renminbi

1948-1949: The Renminbi was introduced by the People’s Bank of China shortly before the establishment of the People’s Republic of China in 1949. It replaced various forms of currency circulating in the different areas controlled by the Communists and was aimed at providing a stable and unified currency for the new country.

Early Years and Reforms

1955: The first major currency reform took place, aimed at curbing inflation that had spiraled in the early years of the PRC. This reform introduced new banknotes and coins and revalued the RMB.
1960s-1970s: During the Cultural Revolution, China’s economy was largely closed off from the world, and the RMB played a minimal role in international trade.

Opening Up and Economic Reforms

1978: The initiation of economic reforms under Deng Xiaoping marked the beginning of China’s opening up to the world. These reforms gradually led to increased trade and foreign investment, necessitating a more flexible and internationally engaged currency system.
1994: A significant currency reform was implemented to streamline the dual exchange rate system that existed at the time into a single, managed exchange rate system. This reform also aimed to stabilize the RMB and encourage foreign trade and investment.

Internationalization of the RMB

2009: The Chinese government launched the RMB Internationalization strategy, allowing the RMB to be used for cross-border trade. This marked a significant shift towards integrating the RMB into the global financial system.
2010: China allowed the RMB to be traded in offshore markets, notably in Hong Kong, which led to the development of the offshore RMB (CNH) market. This move was crucial for the RMB’s internationalization.
2015-2016: The International Monetary Fund (IMF) included the RMB in its Special Drawing Rights (SDR) basket, a basket of international reserve currencies, recognizing the RMB as a global reserve currency. This inclusion was a milestone in the internationalization of the RMB, reflecting China’s growing importance in the global economy.

Recent Developments

21st Century: China has continued to liberalize its currency regime, with gradual moves towards a more market-oriented exchange rate and increased convertibility of the RMB under the capital account. Despite these reforms, China maintains a cautious approach to capital flows and the exchange rate to ensure economic stability.
Current: The RMB is now one of the world’s top five most-used currencies for global payments, according to SWIFT, reflecting its growing acceptance in international transactions.

The history of the yuan/Renminbi is closely intertwined with China’s modern history, reflecting the country’s transition from a closed, centrally planned economy to a major player in the global economy. The RMB’s journey from a domestic currency to a significant international currency illustrates China’s aspirations and challenges in the global financial landscape.

CNY & CNH

In the context of international forex markets, you’ll encounter two different codes for the Chinese currency: CNY and CNH. These represent two forms of the Chinese yuan but are used in slightly different contexts and markets. Understanding the difference between CNY and CNH is crucial for anyone dealing with international finance or currency exchange involving China.

CNY (Onshore Yuan)

Definition: CNY stands for the Chinese Yuan used within mainland China. It is often referred to as the “onshore yuan.”
Regulation: The value of CNY is regulated by the People’s Bank of China (PBoC), the central bank of China. The PBoC sets a daily midpoint rate for the currency against other major currencies and allows it to fluctuate within a narrow band around this midpoint.
Convertibility: CNY is subject to capital controls imposed by the Chinese government, which restricts the ability to freely exchange the currency for foreign currencies within mainland China.

CNH (Offshore Yuan)

Definition: CNH stands for the Chinese Yuan traded outside of mainland China, especially in Hong Kong. It is known as the “offshore yuan.”
Regulation: Unlike CNY, the value of CNH is not directly controlled by the People’s Bank of China and is subject to market forces. The offshore yuan market was established to enable more international use of the yuan and allow it to trade freely without the capital controls applicable to the onshore yuan.
Convertibility: CNH can be freely traded with other currencies and is used for international transactions, investments, and as a hedging instrument against yuan currency risks.

Key Differences

Location and Regulation: The primary difference between CNY and CNH is where and how they are traded. CNY is used within mainland China with its value controlled by the Chinese central bank, while CNH is traded outside mainland China, especially in Hong Kong, and its value is determined by market forces.
Convertibility and Use: CNH was introduced to facilitate international trade and investment activities without the restrictions that apply to CNY due to China’s capital control policies. This makes CNH a more flexible option for international investors and traders.
Price Difference: Although CNY and CNH represent the same currency, they can trade at slightly different rates due to the different regulatory environments and market conditions. The divergence in their values can indicate market sentiment towards China’s economic policy, capital flows, or expectations of currency appreciation or depreciation.

The existence of CNY and CNH allows China to maintain control over its domestic economy while also promoting the yuan’s use in global markets. For international businesses, investors, and traders, understanding the distinctions between CNY and CNH is essential for making informed decisions in currency markets and managing exposure to yuan-related risks.

Unraveling the Renminbi and Yuan: A Guide for Newcomers to China

Understanding the terms “RMB” and “Yuan” is essential for grasping the basics of China’s modern currency system. Both terms relate to China’s official currency but are used in slightly different contexts.

Historical Context and Definitions

RMB: RMB stands for “Renminbi,” which means “People’s Currency” in Mandarin. It is the official currency of the People’s Republic of China, introduced by the Communist Party in 1949 when it came to power. The RMB is issued by the People’s Bank of China, the country’s central bank.
Yuan: The yuan (元, CNY) is the basic unit of the Renminbi. In the context of currency, it’s similar to how the dollar is to the United States Dollar (USD) or pound is to the British Pound Sterling (GBP). When people in China talk about prices or costs, they often refer to the amount in “yuan.”

Relationship and Usage

RMB vs. Yuan: The relationship between RMB and yuan can be compared to that between the British Pound Sterling and pound. “Renminbi” (RMB) is the official name of the currency, while “yuan” is a unit of the currency. Just as one might say something costs “50 pounds” in the UK, in China, one would say it costs “50 yuan.”

Domestic and International Use

Domestic Use: Within China, prices and transactions are typically denoted in yuan. This is the currency used for all forms of transactions within the country, from buying groceries to paying for services.
International Use: On the international stage, the currency is often referred to as the RMB. However, its international code is “CNY” (Chinese Yuan), which you might see in foreign exchange markets. While traditionally the RMB was not freely convertible on international markets due to China’s strict capital controls, in recent years, there has been a push to internationalize the RMB, making it more widely used and accepted for international transactions, investments, and as a reserve currency.

Government Handling and Policy

The Chinese government, through the People’s Bank of China, manages the RMB with various policies aimed at controlling inflation, managing the exchange rate, and regulating the flow of capital in and out of the country. The government’s approach to currency management has evolved, with significant reforms aimed at liberalizing and internationalizing the RMB, especially with the inclusion of the RMB in the International Monetary Fund’s Special Drawing Rights (SDR) basket in 2016, which marked a milestone in its global acceptance.

Explaining to an Outsider

If you’re coming from outside China and trying to understand the currency, think of the “Renminbi” (RMB) as the name of the currency system, like “British Pound Sterling” or “United States Dollar,” and “yuan” as the basic unit of that currency, like “pound” or “dollar.” While you’ll use yuan for everyday transactions within China, the term RMB is more commonly used in international finance and trade contexts. However, they refer to the same currency, and the distinction is more about context than any functional difference between the two terms.

Conclusion

China’s innovative paper money, while groundbreaking, experienced a complex journey in international trade.

Early limitations: While revolutionary, its international use was initially limited by global acceptance and the continued reliance on precious metals and barter systems. Its influence would ultimately extend through the gradual adoption by other countries.
Domestic impact: Within China, paper money significantly impacted society and the economy. It facilitated trade, improved government control, and became permanently rooted in their financial system. Its success and challenges offered valuable lessons for other cultures developing their own currencies.
Origins and drivers: The invention wasn’t simply due to paper, but due to a unique combination of factors. China’s advanced paper and printing, a growing economy demanding efficient transactions, and a centralized government enforcing value and circulation all contributed to its success.
Historical context: China’s monetary system had a rich history, evolving from various forms of money before the invention of paper. This evolution wasn’t due to a lack of existing options, but rather a response to the limitations of metal currency in a growing and complex economy.

In conclusion, paper money’s impact transcended mere technological innovation. It served as a catalyst for domestic growth while highlighting both limitations and opportunities on the international stage.

—

This page was last updated on February 25, 2024.

–